What I ended up with:
The material is an old shirt of mine that was one of Mr. Curly's favorite while we were dating.
1: I STINK at using Mod-podge glue. Well, almost any glue really, but especially at spreading mod-podge glue with a butter knife over dyable wedding shoes.
2: I ended up finishing off edges with a low-temp glue gun.
I like how they look, but they could use some clean up. A little more trimming, a few more glue gun spots.
The good news is, the material pulls off SUPER easy. So I can either re-glue the same material, or change it every week according to what I want to wear the next day. I wore them on Sunday with a black skirt and a pink peasent shirt and looked super cute (if I don't say so myself).
I'm considering starting a little etsy shop selling mod-podge shoes, but since I didn't come up with the idea myself, I'm not sure that's entirely legal (or nice to the people who were willing to share the idea). Maybe I'll just buy super cheap shoes on sale at Walmart and Payless and continue to make something fun for myself. And I'm sure Curly Girl, who found a pair of pink sparkly shoes that she REALLY wanted the other day, would appreciate some new glitter satin on her sandels!